Elden Ring's DLC has introduced a variety of remembrance rewards, enhancing gameplay with new weapons, spells, and other items. We've taken the liberty to rank all 23 remembrance rewards from the best to the worst, explaining each to help players understand their potential pros and cons.

Elden Ring DLC Best Remembrance Reward Tier List

These Remembrance rewards in Elden Ring DLC include a variety of powerful weapons, spells, and talismans that can be very useful for players to obtain and incorporate into their builds. The rewards cover a wide range of playstyles and damage types, from melee weapons to sorceries and incantations.

1. Staff of the Great Beyond

The Staff of the Great Beyond is the pinnacle of versatility in spellcasting. It allows you to cast any spell under any condition, eliminating the need for multiple catalysts. Its scaling is impressive at 1.38 for both Intelligence and Faith, making it the top choice for hybrid builds. This staff offers unparalleled flexibility and power, deserving its place at the top.

2. Spear of the Impaler

This spear excels with its multi-hit weapon skill, which synergizes well with the Winged Sword Talisman. Its fire wave extends further than expected, catching enemies off-guard. The spear's hyper armor is just right, and its charged R2 is enhanced by the Smithing Talisman. It's a powerful and versatile weapon that enhances mounted combat, making it a must-have.

3. Sword Lance

A versatile weapon for strength builds, the Sword Lance offers a unique running R2 akin to a spear's moveset, allowing for multiple hits per attack. Its heavy affinity scaling is nearly S-tier, making it a fantastic choice for both high attack ratings and status builds. This weapon is a jack-of-all-trades, perfect for any strength-focused adventurer.

4. Blades of Stone

The Blades of Stone received significant buffs in patch 1.13, boosting its damage and range. It's now more effective at hitting targets consistently, making it a reliable choice for drilling through tough enemies. Its improvements are evidence of the developers addressing player feedback, enhancing its overall performance.

5. Messmer's Orb

Despite lacking hyper armor, Messmer's Orb shines with its spatial awareness demands. It's a well-balanced incantation with above-average damage. While some claim it's underwhelming, its effectiveness can be unlocked with proper positioning, making it a solid choice for strategic players.

6. Shadow Sunflower Blossom

This weapon skill racks up immense damage quickly, offering a balance between physical and holy damage. It's an excellent choice for those looking to maximize damage output without sacrificing versatility. The Shadow Sunflower Blossom is both powerful and visually impressive.

7. Greatsword of Damnation

The Greatsword of Damnation surprises with its strength weapon classification. Its Ash of War provides excellent hyper armor and a unique corkscrew attack. While it could offer more in terms of animation, its high motion values make it a formidable choice for dueling.

8. Putrescence Cleaver

Though its stat requirements seem odd, the Putrescence Cleaver is a powerhouse against fire knights. It offers high strength scaling and frostbite buildup, making it a potent weapon for those willing to adapt to its quirks.

9. Greatsword of Radahn (Lord)

Despite its complex balancing, the Greatsword of Radahn (Lord) remains one of the best weapons in the game. Its holy damage scales with Intelligence, providing massive damage potential. It's a testament to the game's intricate design, offering a rewarding experience for those who master it.

10. Vortex of Putrescence

The Vortex of Putrescence received buffs in patch 1.13, increasing its damage and frostbite buildup. It punishes aggressive enemies with ease, though its two-slot requirement may deter some players. It's a strong choice for those seeking high damage output.

11. Bayle's Tyranny

Bayle's Tyranny offers impressive fire and lightning damage, despite lacking interaction with the Roar Medallion. It's a solid incantation that excels with proper boosts, making it a reliable option for diverse builds.

12. Rellana's Twin Blades

These blades offer balanced scaling across multiple stats, making them a versatile choice for various builds. Though their stance attacks lack hyper armor, their even scaling ensures no build goes wrong with them.

13. Bayle's Flame Lightning

Bayle's Flame Lightning is highly buffable, with three separate damage types. However, it requires precision and heavy stat investment. It's a niche choice that excels when built correctly.

14. Divine Beast Frost Stomp

While not particularly strong unless heavily invested in Intelligence, Divine Beast Frost Stomp benefits from charging, increasing its magic damage and frostbite buildup. It's a decent tool for status effects rather than raw damage.

15. Enraged Divine Beast

This niche talisman boosts a select set of moves by 10%. While its range of applications is limited, it can be the best choice for specific builds focused on those abilities.

16. Gazing Finger

The Gazing Finger scales with both Intelligence and Faith, contrary to popular belief. It's a slow grind to level, but its unique skill offers a versatile option for those willing to invest the time.

17. Poleblade of the Bud

Poleblade of the Bud has decent potential with proper dedication, especially for rot builds. Though it lacks Arcane scaling, it can still be effective when paired with the right weapons and skills.

18. Greatsword of Radahn (Light)

Despite its post-patch buffs, the Greatsword of Radahn (Light) falls short compared to its boss counterpart. Its visual effects are impressive, but its damage is underwhelming, making it less desirable.

19. Land of Shadow

This weapon, though visually impressive, doesn't live up to the hype in terms of gameplay impact. It's overshadowed by its more powerful counterparts and by other weapons in the game.

20. Midra's Flame Frenzy

This spell provides a fairly standard damage output but lacks uniqueness, feeling like a rehashed version of other frenzy spells. Its use is niche, and it's typically outclassed by other options in the game.

21. Light of Miquella

Despite its late-game availability and costly nature, Light of Miquella fails to justify its slot in a player's arsenal. The damage output and secondary effects are underwhelming, overshadowed by other spells that cost less and do more.

22. Rellana's Twin Moons

A weapon ash that promises much but delivers little due to its long wind-up time and predictable trajectory. While it might be useful against stationary targets, its overall utility is limited, making it more of a novelty than a game-changer.

23. Rotten Butterflies

Rotten Butterflies ranks as the weakest remembrance reward. Attempting to use this incantation often results in more embarrassment than effectiveness. It requires high foresight and almost perfect conditions to be beneficial, which are hard to come by during chaotic gameplay.

Each of these remembrance rewards offers something unique, and their effectiveness can vary greatly depending on your playstyle and build. Choose wisely, and may your journey through the Lands Between be ever rewarding!